{
  "schema": "vedokrok.public-item.v1",
  "release_id": "VEDOKROK-SEL-5d86e1b23401e578",
  "url": "/knowledge/hungry-judge-effect",
  "id": "MHC-D-A3734D7EF59F",
  "version": "0.1.0",
  "title": "Hungry judge effect",
  "summary": "The famous finding is real data. The popular 'hungry judges get harsher' story is a stronger claim.",
  "kind": "concept",
  "body": "A 2011 parole-board study found favourable decisions were more common early in sessions and after breaks. Hunger was not measured or experimentally assigned, so food, rest, case order, decision time, representation, and scheduling remain competing explanations.",
  "limits": [
    "Treat the result as a warning about sequence and context effects, not as a law that hungry judges become harsher."
  ],
  "topics": [
    "critical-thinking"
  ],
  "intents": [],
  "source_ids": [
    "CB-EVID-8cb1758fed6d32812c0f",
    "CB-EVID-6a42a0c2e5f7a596f16c",
    "CB-EVID-28a2bc51c0446bfceaa1"
  ],
  "evidence": [
    {
      "claim": "The famous 2011 parole-board study found favorable decisions were more common early in a decision session and immediately after food breaks. It did not directly measure hunger, glucose, fatigue, or mood, and the authors explicitly could not separate eating from rest. A contemporaneous critique argued that non-random case ordering could explain the pattern; the original authors disputed that critique with additional analyses. Treating this as a general law that hungry judges become harsher goes beyond the evidence.",
      "source_id": "CB-EVID-8cb1758fed6d32812c0f",
      "role": "contextualizes",
      "note": "Archived evidence status: contested observational finding; hunger interpretation not established. The famous 2011 parole-board study found favorable decisions were more common early in a decision session and immediately after food breaks. It did not directly measure hunger, glucose, fatigue, or mood, and the authors explicitly could not separate eating from rest. A contemporaneous critique argued that non-random case ordering could explain the pattern; the original authors disputed that critique with additional analyses. Treating this as a general law that hungry judges become harsher goes beyond the evidence.",
      "locator": "Extraneous factors in judicial decisions (2011)"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The famous 2011 parole-board study found favorable decisions were more common early in a decision session and immediately after food breaks. It did not directly measure hunger, glucose, fatigue, or mood, and the authors explicitly could not separate eating from rest. A contemporaneous critique argued that non-random case ordering could explain the pattern; the original authors disputed that critique with additional analyses. Treating this as a general law that hungry judges become harsher goes beyond the evidence.",
      "source_id": "CB-EVID-6a42a0c2e5f7a596f16c",
      "role": "contextualizes",
      "note": "Archived evidence status: contested observational finding; hunger interpretation not established. The famous 2011 parole-board study found favorable decisions were more common early in a decision session and immediately after food breaks. It did not directly measure hunger, glucose, fatigue, or mood, and the authors explicitly could not separate eating from rest. A contemporaneous critique argued that non-random case ordering could explain the pattern; the original authors disputed that critique with additional analyses. Treating this as a general law that hungry judges become harsher goes beyond the evidence.",
      "locator": "Overlooked factors in the analysis of parole decisions (2011)"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The famous 2011 parole-board study found favorable decisions were more common early in a decision session and immediately after food breaks. It did not directly measure hunger, glucose, fatigue, or mood, and the authors explicitly could not separate eating from rest. A contemporaneous critique argued that non-random case ordering could explain the pattern; the original authors disputed that critique with additional analyses. Treating this as a general law that hungry judges become harsher goes beyond the evidence.",
      "source_id": "CB-EVID-28a2bc51c0446bfceaa1",
      "role": "contextualizes",
      "note": "Archived evidence status: contested observational finding; hunger interpretation not established. The famous 2011 parole-board study found favorable decisions were more common early in a decision session and immediately after food breaks. It did not directly measure hunger, glucose, fatigue, or mood, and the authors explicitly could not separate eating from rest. A contemporaneous critique argued that non-random case ordering could explain the pattern; the original authors disputed that critique with additional analyses. Treating this as a general law that hungry judges become harsher goes beyond the evidence.",
      "locator": "Reply to Weinshall-Margel and Shapard: Extraneous factors in judicial decisions persist (2011)"
    }
  ],
  "avoid_when": [
    "Treat the result as a warning about sequence and context effects, not as a law that hungry judges become harsher."
  ],
  "steps": [
    "Describe the observed pattern before naming its cause.",
    "Track workload, order, break timing, case difficulty, representation, and decision duration separately.",
    "If a break effect appears, test competing explanations instead of turning correlation into a story."
  ],
  "example": "Favourable decisions rise after lunch. That pattern is compatible with hunger, rest, scheduling, or case-order effects; the data alone do not choose among them.",
  "check": "Which variables were actually measured, and which causal explanations remain untested?",
  "published_at": "2026-11-13T05:54:13Z",
  "review": {
    "kind": "agent",
    "label": "Agent check of the archived evidence review; no independent human review claimed",
    "reviewed_at": "2026-11-13T05:54:13Z"
  },
  "use_when": [],
  "knowledge_origin": {
    "release_id": "MHC-RPUB-20261113-0d6697fd",
    "corpus_commit": "0d6697fd15f7fb670cfa465c54a411e91752cae4",
    "manifest_sha256": "038080ffd768d7c1ae21ae65ea2a3b8e36664c28df759e06d19f63f6e059bf29",
    "projection_sha256": "489520d20496b8e53d4bcf37ddaae13d1b66f4405e33ae1666ce681073b24c78",
    "published_at": "2026-11-13T05:54:13Z"
  },
  "editorial_overlay": null,
  "editorial": null,
  "notices": [],
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "CB-EVID-8cb1758fed6d32812c0f",
      "title": "Extraneous factors in judicial decisions",
      "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21482790/"
    },
    {
      "id": "CB-EVID-6a42a0c2e5f7a596f16c",
      "title": "Overlooked factors in the analysis of parole decisions",
      "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21987788/"
    },
    {
      "id": "CB-EVID-28a2bc51c0446bfceaa1",
      "title": "Reply to Weinshall-Margel and Shapard: Extraneous factors in judicial decisions persist",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1112190108"
    }
  ],
  "relations": [],
  "collections": [
    {
      "id": "RC-MHC-COGNITIVE-BIAS-EVIDENCE-20261113",
      "title": "Question a cognitive shortcut",
      "url": "/collections/question-a-cognitive-shortcut"
    }
  ],
  "topic_hubs": [
    {
      "id": "critical-thinking",
      "title": "Critical thinking and evidence",
      "url": "/topics/critical-thinking"
    }
  ],
  "solution_packs": []
}
