5 cases · about 25 minutes

Think past your first explanation

Weigh the evidence and challenge your first explanation. Make a decision brief.

Checking this browser for earlier practice…

Cold start · no hints yet Case 1 of 5

The evidence that agrees with you

You think a new workflow is slowing your team. Three colleagues complain after the change. Two other teams report finishing similar tasks faster, but you dismiss those reports as exceptions.

How should you test your explanation?

Choose one response
Add your reasoning (optional)
Before checking, how sure are you?
Make your own practice note

Draft a decision you can defend

Use a non-sensitive task. Notes are not saved or sent; copy or download them before leaving.

See a fictional completed note

Fictional example. Use the structure with your own observations and limits.

What decision is in front of you?
Choose a short checklist or a free-form note for an ordinary internal handoff.
What facts support your preferred option?
In two sample handoffs, the checklist named the next owner; one free-form note did not. The tasks differed, so this does not establish a general advantage.
What is the strongest reason it may be wrong?
A checklist may omit unusual context. A free-form note with clear prompts might work equally well.
What evidence would change your mind?
Compare both formats on matched fictional handoffs. Check the next action, owner and missing context. Change the choice if the checklist creates important omissions.
What will you do next?
Try the checklist on one non-sensitive handoff, leave room for context and review the receiver's next action. Keep the choice provisional.
Check your own note

0 / 5 fields have text. Check the substance before you use this draft.

  • The decision names real alternatives and why a choice is needed.
  • Observations stay distinct from the interpretation they might support.
  • The strongest plausible objection or rival gets a fair test.
  • The brief says what could change the choice and names a proportionate next step.

This is your draft. No AI review is performed.