Concept

Decoy effect

An option nobody should choose can still change what people choose.

About 1 min read

Keep this limit in mind

  • Not every three-tier menu creates a decoy effect. The structure of the choice set and the attributes compared matter.

An idea to explore.

Try this idea.

Inspect the example, try the idea in your situation, then check your next move.

Keep reading

The idea

The decoy effect occurs when adding an inferior option changes the relative appeal of the better options. A decoy dominated by one alternative can make that target easier to justify, even though nothing about the target itself changed.

Steps

  1. Compare the main options before and after the extra option appears.
  2. Check whether the suspected decoy is clearly worse than one option on the important attributes.
  3. Remove the decoy and see whether your preference between the remaining choices changes.

An example

A pricing table adds a plan that costs almost as much as the premium plan but offers less. The premium plan suddenly looks like the obvious bargain.

Check your result

If you delete the inferior option, do you still prefer the same main option for the same reasons?

Save and practise this idea

My learning

Read. Recall. Repeat.

Save this idea and return to it on any device.

Use email
Keep exploring

More from this collection

Question a cognitive shortcut

Default effectDenomination effect
Evidence and sources
Provides context

The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

Archived evidence status: well documented, context-dependent. The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

Choice in Context: Tradeoff Contrast and Extremeness Aversion · Choice in Context: Tradeoff Contrast and Extremeness Aversion (1992)

Provides context

The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

Archived evidence status: well documented, context-dependent. The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

The asymmetric dominance effect: Reexamination and extension in risky choice – An experimental study · The asymmetric dominance effect: Reexamination and extension in risky choice – An experimental study (2019)

Provides context

The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

Archived evidence status: well documented, context-dependent. The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

Revisiting the decoy effect: replication and extension of Ariely and Wallsten (1995) and Connolly, Reb, and Kausel (2013) · Revisiting the decoy effect: replication and extension of Ariely and Wallsten (1995) and Connolly, Reb, and Kausel (2013) (2021)

Provides context

The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

Archived evidence status: well documented, context-dependent. The decoy effect is a well-documented family of context effects in which adding an inferior or otherwise strategically positioned alternative can change choice shares among the original options. The classic attraction effect uses an asymmetrically dominated decoy that is worse than the target but not necessarily worse than the competitor. The effect is not guaranteed: its size depends on the geometry of the options, prior preferences, task design and other moderators, and preregistered replications have found both successful and weak or null results.

An integrative review of the decoy effect on choice behavior · An integrative review of the decoy effect on choice behavior (2024)

All sources (4)
Edition and review

Version 0.1.0 · Published

Edition checked · 2026-11-13

Read this idea as JSON · Release details